At the conclusion of a St. Louis City personal injury trial, the court awarded plaintiff just $750—substantially less than the $900,000 pre-suit demand made against Adam McGonigle’s client.
Plaintiff alleged he sustained a debilitating and permanent knee injury after a bus door closed on his leg. HeplerBroom’s transportation company client admitted liability but vigorously contested causation and damages. Plaintiff’s claimed damages included two surgeries, years of physical therapy, and nearly a decade of lost wages.
However, during discovery, the defense uncovered medical records revealing multiple prior undisclosed knee injuries and a history of claimed disability. This discovery contradicted plaintiff’s denial of any pre-existing conditions, evidence that proved critical in significantly limiting the damages awarded.
McGonigle, a partner in the firm’s St. Louis office, was assisted at trial by associate attorney Gabrielle Deimeke. McGonigle concentrates his practice on litigation and trial work involving the defense of personal injury cases and trucking and transportation matters. He has been named to Best Lawyers’ “Ones to Watch” and is a co-recipient of Missouri Lawyers Media’s #4 Top Defense Verdict in Missouri for 2024.